The breakdown is simple: there are two free agents and one 3rd string quarterback spot available for the Chicago Bears. In the maroon and white corner, a 6'2" 214 pound QB from Southern Illinois, Nick Hill. And in the green and white corner, a 6'2" 236 pound QB from Colorado State, Caleb Hanie. Before even breaking down how each quarterback performed in day one of Bears rookie minicamp, the stats each put together in college tell two contrasting styles*:
Nick Hill
YEAR CMP ATT YDS CMP% YPA LNG TD INT SACK RAT
2005 15 20 288 75.0 14.40 57 3 0 0 245.46
2006 121 196 1721 61.7 8.78 80 15 4 15 156.67
2007 258 361 3175 71.5 8.80 69 28 7 21 167.06
Caleb Hanie
YEAR CMP ATT YDS CMP% YPA LNG TD INT SACK RAT
2004 85 147 1204 57.8 8.19 42 8 7 10 135.05
2005 13 29 251 44.8 8.66 54 2 0 2 140.29
2006 209 342 2427 61.1 7.10 83 11 12 37 124.31
2007 188 293 2455 64.2 8.38 70 18 15 34 144.58
First, the pros for Hill: He has fewer interceptions, and finishes better statistically in completion percentage, yards per attempt, touchdowns and quarterback rating. Also, Hill is more of a runner, he has rushed for more than 100 yards in every season, something Hanie never did. It would seem Hill has a distinct advantage until you consider that Hanie has more experience as a college quarterback and plays a much tougher schedule.
As for now, perhaps the toughest adjustment for a college quarterback is learning not just a new system, but a much tougher and denser system. Playbooks in the NFL are exponentially thicker than in college so any additional studying a player can do in his off time is extraordinarily beneficial. Offensive coordinator Ron Turner made sure to point that out when complimenting Hill after day one. In terms of fundamentals, both QBs did have some trouble completing out routes and more complex patterns and Hill did have an interception or two. But the training for these young guys has to be positive when you consider just how stout the Bears defense has been the last few seasons. So the competition between the two should remain fierce and there's always a chance it will not get settled until the roster deadline.
Sidenote: This of course assumes Chicago doesn't add a veteran quarterback to its roster, perhaps Vinny Testaverde.
*Courtesy espn.com